In the protection philosophy of electrical power systems, "Selectivity" is vital for the continuity of the system. When a fault occurs, only the faulty section must be isolated, while the rest of the system remains energized. The most fundamental way to achieve this is through time grading (or time discrimination) between relays.
Core Concept: What is CTI (Coordination Time Interval)?
Referred to as CTI (Coordination Time Interval) in ANSI/IEEE standards and Grading Time in IEC standards, this concept is the minimum time difference between the protective device closest to the fault (Downstream) and the protective device immediately above it (Upstream).
Circuit Breaker Opening Time (Break Time)
The current is not interrupted the exact moment the relay sends a "TRIP" signal. This process consists of mechanical and physical steps:
• Coil Energization: Activation of the trip coil (Shunt Trip).
• Mechanical Separation: Physical separation of the circuit breaker contacts.
• Arc Extinction: Complete extinguishing of the arc formed upon contact separation within vacuum or SF6 gas.
\(t_{cb}\) = Circuit breaker opening time (Break time)
The physical duration between the energization of the circuit breaker's trip coil and the complete extinction of the arc is the interrupting (break) time. For example, in older MV (Medium Voltage) circuit breakers, this is around 0.5 s – 1 s. In modern MV circuit breakers (such as the Siemens 3AF series), this duration is typically between 50 ms and 80 ms (approximately 3–5 cycles).
The upstream relay must wait for the downstream circuit breaker to complete this process.
Note: In ETAP circuit breaker modeling, Break Time encompasses the "Min. Delay" and the associated "Relay Delay." Relay Delay (Internal Relay Delay) is a value assigned based on the premise that a circuit breaker cannot trip itself. Internal Latency is the mandatory hardware time required for the relay processor to detect the fault and close the output relay (dry contact), which is approximately 20–30 ms or less. Here, relay delay refers to the time it takes for the relay to detect the fault, make a decision, close its output contact, and send a "trip" signal to the breaker. In modern numerical (microprocessor-based digital) relays, this is generally between 10–20 ms (0.01 – 0.02 s).
The assumption in ETAP simulation is as follows:
This circuit breaker will operate alongside a relay in the field. The breaker's own mechanical time (Break Time) might be 50 ms. However, even the fastest relay in the world has a delay of at least 10–20 ms. Therefore, for simulation safety, entering only the mechanical time (50 ms) as the Min. Delay value would be an error; it must be entered together with the relay margin (for example, 70–80 ms).
Relay Overshoot Time
This is the time it takes for the upstream relay to confirm that the fault has ended and "stop monitoring" after the fault current has been interrupted. Even when the downstream circuit breaker clears the fault and interrupts the current, the upstream relay cannot detect that the current has stopped within that exact millisecond.
In numerical relays, this duration is quite short (20–30 ms). If this margin is not allowed, the upstream relay may assume the fault is still ongoing and issue an unnecessary trip, even after the downstream circuit breaker has finished its operation.
In electromechanical relays, the rotating disc continues to spin for a while due to inertia/momentum (approximately 100 ms). In numerical (digital) relays, a very brief delay occurs due to processor cycle times and filter algorithms (approximately 20–30 ms).
If this margin is not included in the CTI or time grading, the upstream relay may "overshoot" and trip unnecessarily, even though the fault has been cleared downstream.
\(t_{overshoot}\): Relay Overshoot Time
Error and Safety Margins
No measurement is 100% flawless. Current transformers (CTs) can approach saturation, especially at high short-circuit currents, causing ratio errors. The relay's own internal clock can deviate by around 5%–10%.
• Tolerances: Encompasses the measurement errors of current transformers (CTs) and the timing margins of the relay (typically 5%–10% of the total time, or ~60 ms).
• Safety Margin: An additional security margin added to account for unexpected mechanical slowdowns.
\(t_{error}\): Tolerances and Errors
To manage these uncertainties, an extra "Safety Margin" of around 100 ms – 150 ms is generally added.
\(t_{safety}\): Safety Margin
\(CTI=t_{cb}+t_{overshoot}+t_{error}+t_{safety}\)
(Note: The typo "t_cbi" in the original formula has been corrected to \(t_{cb}\) to match your previous sections.)
In electromechanical relays, 0.3 seconds may be insufficient; in this case, it may be necessary to increase the CTI value to 0.4 s or 0.5 s.
Relay Operating Time
During coordination, the relay operating time (setting time) is taken into account. The relay operating time is the tripping time calculated according to the characteristic curve equation after the TMS (Time Multiplying Setting) value is entered. In this case, the total time is:
Total Time = Relay Operating Time + Internal Relay Delay + Circuit Breaker Interrupting Time (Break Time)
For example, if the relay operating time (i.e., tripping time at the fault current) is taken as 150 ms, Internal Relay Delay = 30 ms, and Circuit Breaker Break Time = 80 ms, the total time is 260 ms.
This value should not be confused with the 300 ms CTI value. The CTI value is the 300 ms time difference between the two relays, which already includes the 110 ms duration (80 ms + 30 ms) mentioned here. In a two-relay system, the total upstream operating time will be 150 ms + 300 ms (CTI) = 450 ms.
Within this 300 ms, the circuit breaker interrupting time (Break Time) and the Relay Delay are already included. Similarly, at the fault current level, the difference between the time value corresponding to the downstream relay's characteristic curve and the time value corresponding to the upstream relay's characteristic curve is the CTI (or time grading) of 300 ms.
• Physical fault clearing time in the system: 260 ms
• Upstream relay trips at: 450 ms
• Resulting safety margin in between: 190 ms
• Relay Overshoot: 30 ms
• Error Margins (CT/Relay): 60 ms
• Safety Margin: 100 ms
NOTE: Calculations are based on IEC 60255 standards and generally accepted engineering practices (IEEE 242 Buff Book).


